Here are our top 25 lists finally. Also check out the Product Shop lists: Albums, EPs, and Singles.
1) The Hold Steady - Boys and Girls in America
When I first heard Boys and Girls in America, I don’t think I would have predicted it would be my favorite for the year. I thought that the polished production and careful arrangements violated the realness of my favorite bar band. But Craig Finn has left his lyrical stomping grounds of the Twin Cities and the characters that he knew there and The Hold Steady is musically reaching farther than their local dives. Their territory has gotten bigger and so has their music. The songs are still set in bars and at parties – and fueled by booze and drugs – but these stories could be happening all over America.
2) The Thermals - The Body, The Blood, The Machine
The Thermals made a leap of faith by ditching the lo-fi simplicity of their three-chord assault and even adding some keyboards, which took their sound out of the garage and into the studio. Hutch Harris spent more time crafting these lyrics than he has in the past and even tried to cut down his rampant cursing. But this leap was not without reason; the resulting album is an apocalyptic vision of a fascist religious state. This album really resonates with me considering our current government. I also appreciate their DIY punk aesthetic that goes all the way down to the collaged album covers.
3) TV On The Radio - Return To Cookie Mountain
When I listen to TV On The Radio’s Return To Cookie Mountain, I try to imagine what Cookie Mountain would be like. I see a thick wooded forest covered in a blanket of dark fog with the rickety cabin at its peak, overlooking a huge metropolis below. Inside this one-lamp shack, there are reassembled transistor radios, exposed circuitry, and loose woofers from busted speakers. When all of these salvaged devices sing together, the haze over the mountain thickens. Tuned Adebimpe’s falsetto singing is similar breeze. That might sound like a bunch of BS but this album is vivid and tireless. However, the cookies will remain a mystery.
4) The Blow - Paper Television
The Blow have four albums, I am not sure why I have not heard of them before their last, Paper Television. Even more boggling is that Khaela Maricich used to be a part of K Records labelmates The Microphones. When I saw her perform at the Fader House during CMJ this year, I was hooked. Khaela is an unassuming Northwestern, who got on stage clad in fleece jacket and clutching only a microphone. She is a casual singer too, but she can spin the everyday mundane thing into a clever lyric, even if it is not in perfect pitch. Her songs are almost like monologues set to music. Just add Jona’s beats, which strike a happy balance between The Neptunes, The Post Service, and The Knife, and you get the folktro (yes, I made that up) duo know as The Blow.
5) Beirut - Gulag Orkestar
Zach Condon is a gypsy. He grew up in Albuquerque, traveled through Europe after high school, and then moved to Brooklyn. So naturally he stumbled upon Balkan gypsy music. The lush orchestration of ukuleles, accordion, trumpets, tambourines, and strings combined with his unwavering voice is both foreign and familiar. Gulag Orkestar is a serene portrait of his travels through pop songs he found in European folk tunes.
6) Regina Spektor - Begin To Hope
7) The Knife - Silent Shout
8) Hot Chip - The Warning
9) Man Man - Six Demon Bag
10) Sunset Rubdown - Shut Up I Am Dreaming
11) Vetiver - To Find Me Gone
12) Archie Bronson Outfit - Derdang Derdang
13) Band Of Horses - Everything All The Time
14) Liars - Drum's Not Dead
15) Matt & Kim - Matt & Kim
16) Brightblack Morning Light - Brightblack Morning Light
17) Belle & Sebastian - The Life Pursuit
18) Islands - Return To The Sea
19) Tom Waits - Orphans: Brawlers, Bawlers, and Bastards
20) Grizzly Bear - Yellow House
21) Pela - Exit Columbia Street
22) Build to Spill - You In Reverse
23) ¡Forward Russia! - Give Me A Wall
24) Herman Dune - Giant
25) Joanna Newsom - Ys
Here's Charles' list...
MY TOP 25 ALBUMS OF 2006, OR MORE LIKE: MY TOP 2 + THE REST
A few thoughts/notes to preface this name dropping show:
1) My music universe runs about 4 genres deep: (1) indie rock; (2) punk/emo; (3) hip hop; (4) commercial pop/r&b. I’ve probably given a spin to every major release from these 4 categories this year. I’m really just seeking exciting music, in whatever form.
2) I don’t really connect with electronic-driven music. I like The Knife, Hot Chip, The Blow, but see it all as just something to dance to. It’s tough for me to find the heart in any of it.
3) For the most part, indie pop doesn’t really do much for me. Bands like Peter Bjorn & John and Belle & Sebastian just sound too sparse and too cute for me. It’s catchy, but I’d rather listen to catchy popular music (J.T., Beyonce, Cassie, etc.).
4) Very few new artists leave a lasting impression on me these days. Annuals? Like em. Tokyo Police Club? Like em. Lupe Fiasco? He’s aiight. But looking back at year-end, they were all just something new to listen to. I put these albums in heavy rotation and enjoyed them for a few weeks, then moved on to the next big thing.
5) It’s tempting to empty out new music recommendations onto a year-end list. And while I listen to quite a bit of obscure stuff, my favorite albums of the year were all fairly well publicized. So I don’t think you really have to dig too deep to find the “best new music”. Here’s a short list of new faves that missed the cut: Cinemechanica, The Kingdom, Oh No
6) My criteria for this list is simple: it’s the music that impacted me the most in 2006. The thing about music is, if it doesn’t really connect with you somehow – if it’s only catchy – it becomes disposable. And honestly, I love everything on this list, but beyond my Top 2 (The Hold Steady and The Thermals), I didn’t really feel a strong connection with anything else this year. So with that said, here’s my Top 2 + the rest…
1) The Hold Steady – Boys and Girls in America
This was a record made for the people. I memorized every word. I saw them live and jumped my little heart out. I not only loved this album, I lived this album. Just as 24 Hour Revenge Therapy was my soundtrack to being 13 years old growing up in San Francisco, Boys and Girls in America has become my soundtrack to being 25 years old trying to make it in New York.
2) The Thermals – The Body, The Blood, The Machine
I love that The Thermals made a big sounding record without any gimmicks. They didn’t beef up the production, experiment with new sounds, bring in guest collaborators. They just stuck with what works, and made it work better than ever.
3) ¡Forward, Russia! – Give Me A Wall
¡Forward, Russia! get labeled post-punk, but have more in common with post-hardcore acts like At The Drive-In than they do with Joy Division or Gang of Four. “Fifteen Pt. 2” is the best screamo track of the year. Plus, Tom Woodhead does the meanest “mic whip” in a live act since Cedric Bixler-Zavala.
4) Ghostface Killah - Fishscale
Almost every track on Fishscale is a hit, but “The Champ” wins out as the most triumphant hip hop joint of the year. Too often, you hear young MCs trying to make this track before they’ve really arrived. Ghost paid his dues, hustled his way to the top, and “The Champ” is the sound of him rightfully claiming his throne.
5) Clipse – Hell Hath No Fury
Between Lord Willin’ and Hell Hath No Fury, Malice and Pusha T have popularized enough new slang to write their own Clip-tionary. These cats are so trill, they just grindin’, all they do is wamp! wamp!
6) Silversun Pickups – Carnavas
The best commercial rock album of 2006. It just happens to be on an indie label.
7) The Roots – Game Theory
Fuck a mash-up. ?uestlove & Co. one-up every riff-rock beat by slicing up their own tracks organically. And props to Black Thought for reinventing himself as the new Chuck D.
8) Lily Allen – Alright, Still
Lily Allen is so damn charming. If you don’t like her, you’re probably trying to not like her.
9) Justin Timberlake – FutureSex/LoveSounds
It’s great to be self-aware and have great taste and all. But I don’t ever want to take music so seriously that I can’t enjoy something like this. If you’ve set foot on a dance floor these past six months, you’ve probably seen how “SexyBack” and “My Love” (in its various incarnations) kick the energy up to another level. And you can play FutureSex out for another year, cause it has another 5 singles left in it.
10) These Arms Are Snakes – Easter
TAAS understand what 96% of post-hardcore bands don’t get these days—which is, to scream, you have to know what you’re screaming about. Never once does their anger seem forced or misguided, and as a result, there is some real emo-tion here.
These Arms Are Snakes – Crazy Woman Dirty Train (mp3)
11) Mew – And The Glass Handed Kites
If you don’t get into this album right away, give it 10 more spins. Cause once you get into it, it’ll cast a spell on you.
12) Emily Haines & The Soft Skeleton – Knives Don’t Have Your Back
This is the sound of pain. I’ve read reviews complaining that Emily Haines never picks up the pace, but if she had, it wouldn’t have felt right. This is a mood piece, and has found a place in my collection alongside Grace and Let It Die.
13) DJ Drama & Lil Wayne – Dedication 2
Best rapper in the game? That’s a stretch. But on this mixtape, Lil Birdman outshined some other dude calling himself King of the South. Weezy flipped on all of us with “Georgia…Bush”. The stage is set for Tha Carter III as the most anticipated rap release of ’07 – and no, I’m not forgetting Detox.
14) Nelly Furtado - Loose
Loose probably gets left off most year-end lists cause only half the album is worth listening to. But I like half this album better than a full album of anything lower on this list. After churning out 3 of the hottest singles of 2006, Loose could also drop 3 of the hottest singles of 2007: “Do It”, “Glow”, and “Wait For You”
15) Camp Lo - Fort Apache (The Mixtape Album)
What does Camp Lo have to do to get some respect in the rap game? Uptown Saturday Night has been deceptively influential in the world of jiggy rap. Let’s Do It Again was a gem of a follow-up that fell victim to Industry Rule #4080. It’s only fitting that this mixtape came in under the radar. I hope Camp Lo gets some decent promotion (or at least a Pitchfork plug or three) when their next LP drops, cause this is crossover rap that will bump anywhere: on the radio, in the clubs, from hipst__s’ MacBooks.
Camp Lo – Bed Rock (mp3 – recommended to anyone who likes Clipse)
16) Yeah Yeah Yeahs – Show Your Bones
I loved Fever To Tell back in 2003. I can’t bring myself to listen to it anymore. This may not be a popular opinion, but I’m glad YYYs moved away from post-punk. They’ve lost some momentum temporarily by abandoning the sound of the moment, but the shift towards straight up rock-n-pop should give them more longevity than The Strokes and The Rapture, who are stuck in the same tired sound.
17) Thursday – A City By The Light Divided
This is emo music for twenty and thirty somethings. It’s heavy stuff. I don’t think emo has ever sounded so mature. I would love to see bands like Brand New and Taking Back Sunday take a larger step toward this direction as they grow older.
18) The Game – Doctor’s Advocate
The Game is just getting comfortable as the new King of the Left Coast. Doctor’s Advocate shows he’s not afraid to show a little levity, and that should help keep him at the top for a while.
19) T.I. - King
When are people going to figure out that T.I. of 2006 = Ja Rule of 2001? For all his swagger and charisma, there’s not much to T.I. beyond that voice. But King works cause you got that voice backed by high-budget production. I’ll probably end up tossing King into the bargain bin as I did with Pain is Love, but for a five month span in 2006, this was my go-to rap album.
20) TV On The Radio – Return To Cookie Mountain
It’s a tough pill to swallow, but when I was in the mood for it, Cookie Mountain was some of the most powerful music I heard in 2006.
21) Bound Stems – Appreciation Night
This album is all over the place, but one of the more exciting releases I’ve heard this year. I think Bound Stems would be best served in the long run if they tighten up their sound, lose the tendency to break every song down into an indie pop hook, and just make really accessible mathy-rock as they do on “Risking Life and Limb for the Coupon”.
22) Amerie – Because I Love It, Vol. 1 (Mixtape)
I have a crush on Amerie, so I may be biased. The beauty of a mixtape is there’s no pressure to manufacture a hit. Amerie sounds so loose here. Has Beyonce, Ciara, or any other R&B diva ever spit with this kind of fire? This mixtape may do her more justice than her forthcoming LP, where she’ll again be restricted by the standard verse-hook-verse-hook-dance break/rap cameo-hook.
Amerie – Blow (mp3)
23) Sunset Rubdown – Shut Up I Am Dreaming
Spencer Krug is all heart. Even when I have no idea what he’s talking about (horsemen? kids sacrificing eyes? say what??), I’m still feeling it.
24) Man Man – Six Demon Bag
Man Man are in a genre of their own – it’s caveman music. You need to listen to it a lot before it stops being annoying, then you’ll start loving it.
25) The Blood Brothers – Young Machetes
You probably need to have ADHD to love The Blood Brothers. So I guess it’s time to pick up my Adderall prescription...